Staten Island
Eltingville
18 closed sales · last 12 months
Updated monthly from closed-sale data.
Great Kills-Eltingville is a neighborhood within South Shore. The median sale price is $591,250, with pricing at $510.71 per square foot. Annual sales volume runs at 10 transactions.
Over the last 12 months, Eltingville has trailed Staten Island it sits within.
Median Price
$733K
Half of sales closed above this price, half below.
Price / SF
$441/SF
Median closed price per square foot.
Closed Sales
18
Number of closed sales in the period.
Price Trend
Last 12 monthsClosed Sales
Who lives here
- 150,590
- Residents
- $108K
- Median household income
- $2K/mo
- Median rent
Source: U.S. Census (ACS), 2023 · Eltingville (3 ZIP codes)
Eltingville on the map
Notable nearby
Restaurants
- Pacific Kitchen0.1 mi
- Patrizias0.1 mi
- Patrizia’s of Brooklyn0.1 mi
Coffee
- The Vintage Tea0.4 mi
- Brew Bar0.5 mi
- Krave It Café0.5 mi
Bookstores
- Great Kills Library0.4 mi
- New York Public Library - Great Kills0.4 mi
- Afrikan Art Book Store1.0 mi
Nightlife & culture
- Bungalow 180.4 mi
- The Ole Swiss0.4 mi
- SMB Studio & Art Lessons0.4 mi
Shopping
- Sunbelievable0.1 mi
- Eltingville Eye Center0.1 mi
- 99 Cents and Discount World0.1 mi
Getting around
Nearest stop: NELSON AV/AMBOY RD · 8 min walk
Schools nearby
- PS 8 Shirlee SolomonElementary · 7 min walk
- PS 42 EltingvilleElementary · 12 min walk
- PS 32 Gifford School (The)Elementary · 13 min walk
- IS 24 Myra S BarnesMiddle · 14 min walk
- PS 55 Henry M BoehmElementary · 18 min walk
- David Marquis School of the Arts (The)other · 22 min walk
Key details
The cost of homes
The median sale price in Great Kills-Eltingville is $591,250, which is lower than the Staten Island median of $765,000 by roughly $174,000. Homes typically sell between $264,250 and $779,000.
Housing stock
10 homes sold annually in this neighborhood, with a price per square foot of $510.71. The interquartile range spans from $264,250 to $779,000, reflecting variability in property values across the area.
Nearby neighborhoods
All figures reflect sales only; rentals are excluded.
Thinking about a move in this neighborhood?
Get a personalized valuation or talk through the market with a local expert.